By Brandon Aday
Founder, Aday Interactive, Inc. · 20+ years in enterprise systems and AI · Published November 20, 2026 · 8 min read
The short answer
Every business may ask every customer for an honest review, but may not buy reviews, write fake ones, hide bad ones, or ask only happy customers. Regulated firms add more: law firms follow their state's testimonial rules, medical practices may never confirm a patient in a reply, and advisers need SEC disclosures on testimonials they use.
Reviews are one of the first things people check before they call, and they feed the map results and AI answers that send clients your way. So every marketing plan says to get more of them. But how you ask, what you offer, and how you reply are all governed by rules, and in regulated fields there are more of them than most firms realize.
Here is the baseline every business follows, then the extra rules by industry, then a simple way to ask that stays inside all of them.
The FTC rule. Since October 21, 2024, the FTC's Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465, bans fake reviews, including ones written by AI, buying reviews that express a particular opinion, undisclosed reviews by officers and managers, company-run "independent" review sites, and suppressing negative reviews through threats or false accusations. Knowing violations can bring civil penalties.
Endorsements. The FTC's Endorsement Guides, 16 CFR Part 255, expect any material connection, such as a discount, a gift, or a family tie, to be disclosed next to the praise.
Platform policies. Google's policy for Maps reviews prohibits discouraging negative reviews or selectively soliciting positive ones. That rules out review gating, where you survey customers first and send only the happy ones to Google. Yelp goes further and asks businesses not to request reviews at all. Each platform's rules apply on that platform.
Law firms. State bar rules govern testimonials. In Florida, Rule 4-7.13(b)(9) allows them only when they meet its conditions, including a statement that a prospective client may not obtain the same or similar results. The testimonial must come from a real client, and the firm may not pay for it. Replies to reviews also have to protect client confidences, so never discuss a matter in public, even to correct the record.
Medical and dental practices. A reply that confirms someone is a patient, or mentions their care, can disclose protected health information. HHS has settled HIPAA cases with dental practices over exactly this, including a $10,000 settlement in 2019 and a $23,000 settlement in a later case, both over replies to Yelp reviews. Keep replies general, and take the conversation offline.
Wealth and family offices. Under the SEC Marketing Rule, a testimonial used in an advertisement needs clear and prominent disclosures: whether the person is a current client, whether they were paid, and any material conflicts. Reviews you share, edit, or highlight in your marketing can become your testimonials. Set a written policy with your CCO before you ask for reviews.
Real estate. A portal profile with reviews is still advertising. In Florida, Rule 61J2-10.025 requires the licensed brokerage name in every advertisement, so agent and team profiles on Zillow, Realtor.com, and similar sites need it too. The FTC rule applies to reviews from friends, family, and team members.
Tax and accounting firms. Circular 230 §10.30 bars false or misleading claims by tax professionals, and the AICPA Code bars misleading advertising by CPAs. A review that promises a result, such as "they got my penalties wiped out," is safer left unhighlighted than featured on your homepage.
Lenders and fintech. The FTC rule applies in full. If you feature a review that mentions a rate or payment, read it as part of your ad, because lending ad rules apply to what you choose to publish.
Everyone else. Agencies, architects, consultants, hospitality, e-commerce, and SaaS companies follow the FTC rule, the Endorsement Guides, and each platform's policy. For e-commerce and SaaS, disclose every incentive, including free products and gift cards.
Our Growth Systems work builds this into the follow-up itself, so every client gets the same request at the right time, and replies use templates your firm approved in advance.
Look at the last ten replies your firm posted to reviews, and the testimonials on your website. If either names a matter, a treatment, or a result, start there. Law, medical, wealth, real estate, and tax firms can run our free compliance scans for law, medical, wealth, real estate, and accounting to check the testimonials on their site.
Not one that depends on the review being positive. The FTC rule on consumer reviews bans paying for reviews that express a particular opinion. Any incentive for an honest review should be disclosed, and some platforms ban incentives entirely, so check the platform's own policy too.
Review gating means asking customers how they feel first, then sending only the happy ones to Google. Google's policy for Maps reviews prohibits selectively soliciting positive reviews and discouraging negative ones. The safe practice is to ask every customer the same way, with the same link.
With a short, general reply that does not confirm the person is a patient or mention any care, such as thanking them and inviting them to call the office. HHS has settled HIPAA cases with dental practices that disclosed patient information in replies to Yelp reviews, including a $10,000 settlement in 2019 and a $23,000 settlement after that.
Yes, with conditions. Florida's Rule 4-7.13(b)(9) allows testimonials only when they meet its requirements, including a statement that a prospective client may not obtain the same or similar results. The person must be a real client, and the firm may not pay for the testimonial. Have ethics counsel review your testimonial pages.
Reviews you neither control nor promote are generally not your advertising. But once a firm shares, edits, or highlights client reviews in its marketing, they can become testimonials under the SEC Marketing Rule, which then require clear disclosures about client status, compensation, and conflicts. Your CCO should set the policy.
Informational and educational purposes only
This article reflects Aday Interactive, Inc.'s views on marketing and technology architecture for professional-services firms as of the publication date. Aday Interactive, Inc. is not a law firm, and Brandon Aday is not a lawyer or legal counsel. It is not a substitute for advice from a licensed professional in your jurisdiction and does not create any professional relationship between you and Aday Interactive, Inc. Rules, statutes, checklists, and AI-engine behavior referenced here can change; verify the current versions and consult qualified counsel before acting. Where the article discusses bar advertising rules, statutes, or professional conduct requirements, those references are for informational and educational purposes only and do not constitute legal advice. Consult a lawyer licensed in your jurisdiction before acting on anything you read here. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship with Aday Interactive, Inc. or with any attorney.